Should we have a tag for scenes without dialogue?

StashDB
1

We already have language tags like English Language, German Language, French Language, Spanish Language, Japanese Language, Italian Language, etc.

Should we have another tag for scenes where they don’t speak any language at all? Or would that be a pointless tag that nobody ever uses?

I can see it having some benefit for Dorcel films, since some of them have dubbing in various languages, while others get around this by lacking dialogue.

Of course, the big drawback to this tag is that you cannot really apply it without watching much of a scene, since dialogue is sparse in many porn films.

2

Officially I think it will be a hard no on StashDB. Unofficially, yes I do tag “No-Dialogue” on mine.

It certain help as I know this video have no dialogue/audio.

3

Alright. So one other person does this.

But why do you think that this cannot happen on StashDB?

4

There is a Music: Features music playing for most of the scene's length.

I recognize that’s not the same thing as No Talking/Dialogue, but, in my experience, it’s a rare scene that doesn’t have music or talking/dialogue,

5

Your experience is definitely your experience then. Perhaps it depends on which studios you watch. A lack of dialogue is rather common for European studios like Dorcel and 21 Sextury. Even Sexart often has little or no dialogue.

For Dorcel in particular, I think it’s convenient to know which scenes have dialogue and which do not.

6

I just reckon they consider it redundant tag, and want to keep it clean. Don’t know who run the DB and I dont have deep knowledge.